Google’s John Mueller warned that answering Googlebot with a 200 while a site is down creates two distinct indexing problems. He made the case in a LinkedIn comment, replying to Ty Holland, who asked whether a “back soon” message on a 200 is only risky for longer outages or also for a few hours.
Mueller’s first concern is that the page “can get indexed with whatever ‘try again later’ text is visible.” He added that this fixes itself automatically once the real content returns. The second concern is slower to undo. Such a page “can get dup-eliminated with any of the other sites showing that same text,” and Mueller said reversing that can take quite some time, since Google revisits duplicate pages less frequently.
Mueller did not give a duration threshold for when the risk begins, so the answer to Holland’s hours-versus-days question stays open. Search Engine Roundtable, which covered the exchange, did not report one either.
Maintenance pages deserve a check now: confirm your platform returns an error status, not a 200, during planned downtime, because the deduplication tail outlasts the outage itself.
Search Engine Roundtable, Barry Schwartz, November 17, 2026.